Author: University of Birmingham
Author Contact: birmingham.ac.uk
Published: 8th Oct 2023
Peer-Reviewed Publication: Yes
Additional References: Discrimination and Abuse Publications
Summary: A new study reveals the absence of sexually related injuries cannot be used in court to infer that rape victims are making it up.
Experts analyzed the last 30 years of published medical research to compare anogenital injury (AGI) in women who had been raped with those who had engaged in consensual sex.
Experts analyzed the last 30 years of published medical research to compare anogenital injury (AGI) in women who had been raped with those who had engaged in consensual sex.
Examining data from more than 3,000 women, they found that more than half of rape survivors had no detectable injuries, even when examined by experts using forensic dyes and magnification techniques, whilst detectable anogenital injury could be found in 30% of consenting women.
Publishing their findings in eClinicalMedicine, researchers from the University of Birmingham and UK National Health Service specialists in Glasgow, Liverpool and Bristol conclude that absence of AGI is neither proof of consent nor disproof of penetration.
Co-author Dr David Naumann, from the University of Birmingham, commented:
"Women may not disclose rape in the false belief that they won't be able to prove assault if there are no injuries to their genital area. The presence or absence of anogenital injury may also influence law enforcement officers and jurors in the way they perceive the alleged assault."
"Our study provides definitive evidence that absence of injury cannot be used in court to infer that rape did not occur and victims are 'making it up'. We hope our findings help to directly challenge rape myths and empower survivors to report their assault and bring the perpetrators to justice. The absence of AGI is neither proof of consent nor disproof of penetration."
The systematic review demonstrates that although AGI is significantly more likely following sexual assault (48% SA vs 31% CSI), both groups have a combination of detected AGI and absence of AGI.
Physical examination findings for women following sexual assault may be used in court as forensic evidence. Based on these data, there is no case for discrediting allegations of rape based on intimate physical examination alone.
The 2030 UN Agenda for Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), adopted by member countries in 2015, calls for the elimination of violence against women and girls. However, according to UK Government figures, in 2019/2020, only 4% of sexual offences, and 2% of rape offences led to alleged perpetrators being charged or summonsed in the same year.
A significant proportion of these cases are recorded by police as being closed with the outcome "evidential difficulties, victim does not support action" - indicating that the rape survivor withdrew from the process.
Dr Naumann added:
"Numerous myths reinforce cultural attitudes towards reporting of sexual violence. One such myth anticipates physical violence, and thus injury, to be an inevitable accompaniment to rape. Sexual predators use different strategies, such as the threat of physical force, which reduce the likelihood of AGI."
"If we wish to support rape survivors, the clinical community must send an unambiguous, evidence-based message to ensure that rape myths are fully challenged. This will help survivors have increased confidence that the criminal justice system will support them in their disclosure and reporting of sexual violence."
'Anogenital injuries following non-consensual and consensual penetrative intercourse: a systematic review and meta-analysis' - David N Naumann, Louise Morris, Douglas Bowley, Tracy-Louise Appleyard, Julie Cumming, and Deborah Wardle is published in eClinicalMedicine.
Participating Institutions:
University of Birmingham, UK; Department of Trauma and Emergency General Surgery, University Hospitals Birmingham NHS Foundation Trust, UK; Alder Hey Children's Hospital, Liverpool, UK; North Bristol NHS Trust, Southmead Hospital, UK; and NHS Education for Scotland, Glasgow, UK.
Also See: Neuroscientific Evidence Important for Rape Trials
Lack of Sexually Injuries Does Not Mean Rape Victim Is Making It Up | University of Birmingham (birmingham.ac.uk). SexualDiversity.org makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith. Content may have been edited for style, clarity or length.
Post to Twitter Add to Facebook
Latest Discrimination and Abuse Publications | |
---|---|
The above information is from our reference library of resources relating to Discrimination and Abuse that includes: | |
Language in Sexual Offense Judgments Makes Victims Responsible Judgments are supposed to reflect objectivity of the courts, but when we use language we inevitably express some kind of idea or conception of the world. Publish Date: 19th Sep 2024 | |
Lack of Sexually Injuries Does Not Mean Rape Victim Is Making It Up A new study reveals the absence of sexually related injuries cannot be used in court to infer that rape victims are making it up. Publish Date: 8th Oct 2023 | |
Why Sexually Harassed People Might Not Come Forward Immediately or at All What would a reasonable person do? Exploring the gap between experienced and anticipated responses to sexual harassment. Publish Date: 10th Jun 2023 | |
Some LGBT Allies Don't Want Gay Neighbors Study explores stigmatizing behaviors expressed by avid supporters of sexual minorities in a survey 8.5% who said they were fully accepting of gay people did not want gay neighbors. Publish Date: 6th Mar 2023 |
1Transgender Reporting Guide
How to write about transgender people.
2Am I Gay? Questions to Ask
Think you may be gay or bisexual?
3Glossary of Sexuality Terms
Definitions of sexual terms & acronyms.
4LGBTQ+ Pride Flags
Symbols of Identity and Inclusion.
5LGBT Awareness Dates
Important LGBTQ community awareness days, remembrance dates, and coming pride events.
• Submissions: Send us your coming events and LGBTQ related news stories.
• Report Errors: Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.
• (APA): University of Birmingham. (2023, October 8). Lack of Sexually Injuries Does Not Mean Rape Victim Is Making It Up. SexualDiversity.org. Retrieved November 14, 2024 from www.sexualdiversity.org/discrimination/1183.php
• Permalink: <a href="https://www.sexualdiversity.org/discrimination/1183.php">Lack of Sexually Injuries Does Not Mean Rape Victim Is Making It Up</a>