Saks Fifth Avenue Withdraws Assertion Claiming Transgender People Not Protected by Title VII

Author: National Center for Lesbian Rights
Published: Tuesday 27th January 2015
Summary: U.S. Department of Justice files historic statement in the case asserting that Title VII prohibits discrimination against transgender people.

In two major victories for transgender civil rights, today Saks Fifth Avenue withdrew a motion to dismiss a lawsuit in which Saks had argued that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does not protect transgender workers, and the U.S. Department of Justice filed a historic statement of interest in the same case affirmatively stating that Title VII covers transgender people. This is the first time that the Department has made clear that Title VII prohibits any type of discrimination against transgender people, not just discrimination based on gender stereotypes.

The case involves former Saks employee Leyth Jamal, who filed the lawsuit alleging that Saks discriminated against her for being transgender. Saks withdrew the motion to dismiss the lawsuit in which Saks had argued - contrary to contemporary case law, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, and the U.S. Department of Justice - that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 does not protect transgender workers.

The Human Rights Campaign (HRC) and the National Center for Lesbian Rights (NCLR) - who became involved with the case following Saks' previous incorrect assertions that Title VII protections did not cover transgender people - issued the following statements:

HRC Legal Director Sarah Warbelow said: "Today's historic statement from the Department of Justice makes it very clear that transgender people are indeed protected by Title VII from workplace discrimination. Saks also made the right decision by correcting its dangerous course of legal actions that sought to completely undermine those established protections. We are pleased that the case can now be resolved on the merits of the claims and not a sweeping negation of basic Title VII protections."

NCLR Legal Director Shannon Minter said: "We applaud Saks for correcting its position and recognizing that it has a legal obligation to treat transgender workers equally. We are also grateful to the Department of Justice for clearly stating that federal law prohibits all forms of workplace discrimination against transgender employees. The Department's filing today is historic and will have an enormously positive effect not only in this case, but in other cases across the country."

Last week, HRC and NCLR filed a joint friend of the court brief arguing against Saks' previous assertions. There is a broad legal consensus that Title VII protects transgender employees, and the nation's top law firms - including Saks' own counsel in this case - have publicly advised employers that discrimination against transgender workers violates Title VII. The brief also noted that tens of thousands of employers have taken proactive steps to comply with the law by adopting non-discrimination policies that explicitly protect transgender workers.

In 2012, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) determined in Macy v. Holder that discrimination based on an individual's gender identity is sex discrimination and thus constitutes a violation of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

In 2014, the EEOC filed complaints in federal courts in Florida and Michigan against two separate companies accused of discriminating against transgender employees, Amiee Stephens of Michigan and Brandi Branson of Florida.

In December of 2014, U.S. Attorney General Eric Holder announced that the Department of Justice will no longer assert that "Title VII's prohibition against discrimination based on sex does not encompass gender identity per se (including transgender discrimination.)"

Similar Topics

From our LGBT Rights section - Full List (21 Items)

Send us your coming events and LGBTQ related news stories.

A Summary of Data on LGBT Suicide for Suicide Prevention Month

LGBT People Could Gain Additional Protections from Discrimination After Bostock

HUD Aims to Reverse Protections for Homeless Transgender People Accessing Shelters

Bisexual Women and Girls Reproductive Health Needs Greater Attention

Only 3% of Sexually Active Transgender People Use PrEP

Experiences of Food Insecurity Among Californian LGBTQ

U.S. DOJ Files Statement of Interest Defending Constitutionality of Idaho's Fairness in Women's Sports Act

US Supreme Court Decision Protects 8.1M LGBT Workers From Employment Discrimination

Tsara Shelton
"Storytellers are powerful and we are all storytellers," suggests Tsara Shelton, author of the book Spinning in Circles and Learning from Myself: A Collection of Stories that Slowly Grow Up..

LGBT Awareness & Events
List of important LGBT awareness dates and coming sexual diversity events.

Transgender Reporting Guide - English
Guide for those writing on transgender and LGBT community - Spanish Version.
Sexuality Definitions
List of definitions and glossary of sexual terms, abbreviations and their meanings.