Himpathy Towards Perpetrators of Workplace Sexual Harassment

Author: Syracuse University
Author Contact: syracuse.edu
Published: 20th Mar 2023 - Updated: 11th Apr 2023
Peer-Reviewed Publication: Yes
Additional References: Workplace Discrimination Publications

Summary: A new study suggests that some people are morally biased to have sympathy toward the accused in cases of workplace sexual harassment.

Definition

Himpathy

Himpathy is the excessive sympathy shown toward male perpetrators of sexual violence. Cornell philosophy professor Kate Manne coined Himpathy as "the inappropriate and disproportionate sympathy powerful men often enjoy in cases of sexual assault, intimate partner violence, homicide, and other misogynistic behavior."

Main Document

"Moral Foundations, Himpathy, and Punishment Following Organizational Sexual Misconduct Allegations" - Organization Science.

Managers spend much of their time managing conflict and struggle to know how to respond when a 'he-said-she-said' workplace dispute occurs. However, a new study shows how employees' intuitive moral values might give rise to feelings of sympathy toward alleged perpetrators and anger toward their accusing victims.

The research, published in this month's edition of Organization Science, also offers novel insights into what enables perpetrators to go unpunished and why their victims experience backlash for coming forward.

The research team (which included Samantha Dodson, a postdoctoral research fellow at the University of British Columbia, Rachel Goodwin, assistant professor of management at Syracuse University, and Kristina Diekmann and Jesse Graham, professors from the University of Utah) focused on recent well-publicized cases of sexual harassment.

"We show that third parties - or people like you and me who watched the #MeToo Movement happen - evaluate victims and perpetrators based on their moral values," said Goodwin. "These moral concerns can bias our emotional responses, credibility judgments, and motivations to resolve injustice in favor of the accused or the accuser. For example, we found that people who highly endorse values such as deference to authority, in-group loyalty, and purity tend to be more likely to support the perpetrator rather than the victim."

Workplace sexual misconduct perpetuates costly gender inequality at work and in society.

Efforts to encourage reporting of gender-based discrimination (e.g., sexual misconduct) at work have increased. However, victims who report sexual misconduct in organizations often face significant sanctions for doing so.

Women who make sexual misconduct complaints often experience organizational and third-party retaliation for reporting misconduct (involuntary transfer, poor performance appraisals, job loss, ostracism), which can severely affect their well-being.

In contrast, men accused of engaging in sexual misconduct rarely experience transfers or terminations and are less likely to be terminated or resign than their victims. Further, termination of those accused of sexual misconduct may not prevent perpetrators from gaining power in other organizations.

Although there are recent high-profile cases in the media of men accused of sexual misconduct facing significant penalties, suggesting that organizational responses to sexual harassment allegations have changed following the #MeToo Movement, most of the accused escaped repercussions altogether or recovered from this career setback within a few short years.

This new research explains one reason this may be happening by showing that some people - including managers - may be morally biased against sexual harassment victims and in favor of accused perpetrators. The work was inspired by courageous women like Christine Blasey-Ford, who publicly came forward with #MeToo accusations, despite the 'himpathetic' individuals they were likely to encounter.

References and Source(s):

Himpathy Towards Perpetrators of Workplace Sexual Harassment | Syracuse University (syracuse.edu). SexualDiversity.org makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith. Content may have been edited for style, clarity or length.

Post to Twitter Add to Facebook

Latest Workplace Discrimination Publications
The above information is from our reference library of resources relating to Workplace Discrimination that includes:
	Harsh Workplace Pushing Women Out of Academia Researchers found a harsh workplace climate, which can include harassment and feelings of not belonging, was the most common reason women left academia. Publish Date: 21st Oct 2023
	Himpathy Towards Perpetrators of Workplace Sexual Harassment A new study suggests that some people are morally biased to have sympathy toward the accused in cases of workplace sexual harassment. Publish Date: 20th Mar 2023 - Updated: 11th Apr 2023
	Creamy and Seductive: Gender Surveillance in Flight Attendant Work Despite airline industry attempts to cultivate diverse working environments, gendered practices and pressures persist with female cabin crew encountering expectations on appearance not extended to male counterparts. Publish Date: 17th Jan 2023
	Managers Exhibit Bias Based on Race, Gender, Disability and Sexual Orientation Research reveals those in management positions demonstrate explicit and implicit bias toward others from marginalized groups and often express more implicit bias than those not in management. Publish Date: 2nd Dec 2022