Author: University of Colorado at Boulder
Author Contact: colorado.edu
Published: 21st Jan 2023
Peer-Reviewed Publication: Yes
Additional References: LGBT Adolescents Publications
Summary: U.S. states, including Colorado that have not banned abortion still do require those under age 18 to involve their parents before terminating a pregnancy.
Use of Judicial Bypass of Mandatory Parental Consent to Access Abortion and Judicial Bypass Denials, Florida and Texas, 2018-2021 - American Journal of Public Health.
Twenty-two states, including Colorado, that have not banned abortion still do require those under age 18 to involve their parents before terminating a pregnancy. Their only other option: to seek approval from a judge via a process called judicial bypass.
New University of Colorado research published Jan. 12 in the American Journal of Public Health sheds new light on how many young people must navigate that process, shown in previous research to be traumatizing, and how frequently judges deny them care.
It found that more than one in 10 minors seeking abortions in Texas and Florida between 2018 and 2021 sought judicial bypass, and as many as 13% were denied. About 5,527 minors in Florida and 5,520 in Texas received abortions during the study period.
"States that support abortion rights but continue to mandate parental involvement have a responsibility to consider the true consequences of those mandates," said co-author Amanda Stevenson, assistant professor of sociology at CU Boulder.
She notes that due to recent statewide bans in the wake of the overturning of Roe v. Wade, many minors must now travel across state lines to seek care only to face parental involvement mandates far from home.
"Our research shows that substantial numbers of adolescents cannot involve their parents and rely on judicial bypass, and bypasses are routinely denied."
For the study, Stevenson and co-author Kate Coleman-Minahan, assistant professor at the University of Colorado College of Nursing at the Anschutz Medical Campus, analyzed data on bypass petitions and abortions provided to minors in Florida and Texas between 2018 and 2021.
Florida moved from requiring parental notification to requiring consent in 2020. Texas has required parental consent for years and now has a total abortion ban.
"Florida is more critical than ever as a source of abortion care since it's now the only place in the region to get an abortion after six weeks, so the fact that teenagers face such a large hurdle to get the care it is significant," said Stevenson.
The team's previous research found that some teens seeking judicial bypass have experienced family trauma, household substance abuse, or a general fear for their safety if they were to tell their parents they are seeking an abortion.
Once they begin the bypass process, they're often confronted with challenges taking time off from school, getting to the courthouse, and other obstacles.
Many reported finding the process humiliating and frightening, with judges and court-appointed guardians-ad-litem shaming them.
Judges typically require minors to either provide evidence they are "mature" enough to have an abortion (things such as good grades or participation in extracurricular activities) or prove they can't safely tell their parent, said Coleman-Minahan.
"They are often re-traumatized and re-victimized in court by having to describe their family situations," she said.
The study also sheds some light on how many teens from states where abortion is banned may be seeking abortions elsewhere and potentially running up against parental involvement laws.
"Teenagers who are traveling far to get abortions will also have to involve their parents and get documentation of notification or consent to meet that state's requirement," said Stevenson. "That can be logistically challenging to the point of being impossible."
One Massachusetts study found that complying with parental consent guidelines in the state there took about nine days. For those who sought judicial bypass, it took 15.
Reasons for denials are not typically released, but previous studies have shown judges have denied bypasses based on family socioeconomic status, how far along a person was in their pregnancy, or a judge's personal values.
"Our research shows that this process does not just harm young people, they are denied abortions, and that can have lifelong impacts," said Stevenson.
The authors call on states such as Colorado and Maryland, which allow abortion access but mandate parental involvement, to routinely report the percentage of minors using the judicial bypass system so that coordinated services can be provided to help young people navigate it.
They also hope the data will demonstrate that parental involvement laws, which have been widely supported even among some advocates of abortion rights, harm large numbers of individuals and prevent some from getting the care they need.
"If liberal states and organizations are talking about reproductive justice, then that conversation needs to include the needs of young people, too," said Coleman-Minahan. "They deserve abortion care as much as older people and are often left out of the conversation."
10% of Minors Seeking Abortion Must Pursue Court Approval, Many Are Denied | University of Colorado at Boulder (colorado.edu). SexualDiversity.org makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith. Content may have been edited for style, clarity or length.
|Latest LGBT Adolescents Publications|
The above information is from our reference library of resources relating to LGBT Adolescents that includes:
|10% of Minors Seeking Abortion Must Pursue Court Approval, Many Are Denied|
U.S. states, including Colorado that have not banned abortion still do require those under age 18 to involve their parents before terminating a pregnancy.
Publish Date: 21st Jan 2023
|LGBTQ Youth in Juvenile Correctional Facilities at High Risk for Suicide and Self-Harm|
A new study finds that LGBTQ youth are disproportionally represented in juvenile correctional facilities.
Publish Date: 29th Nov 2022 - Updated: 30th Nov 2022
|Kids Who Doubt Their Gender Identity Enter Puberty Earlier|
A study shows that children who have expressed a desire at age 11 to be a different gender enter puberty earlier than their peers.
Publish Date: 18th Nov 2022
|Educating Young Adolescents About Avoiding Child Sexual Abuse Behaviors|
Controlled trial found increased knowledge about child sexual abuse and related norms and laws, increased intention to avoid or prevent child sexual abuse with younger children.
Publish Date: 3rd Nov 2022 - Updated: 5th Jan 2023
1LGBTQ+ Awareness and Events
LGBTQ+ awareness dates and events.
2Transgender Reporting Guide
How to write about transgender people.
3Glossary of Sexuality Terms
Definitions of sexual terms & acronyms.
4Glossary of Gender Terms
Definitions of gender related terms.
5Am I Gay? Questions to Ask
Think you may be gay or bisexual?
• Submissions: Send us your coming events and LGBTQ related news stories.
• Report Errors: Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.
• (APA): University of Colorado at Boulder. (2023, January 21). 10% of Minors Seeking Abortion Must Pursue Court Approval, Many Are Denied. SexualDiversity.org. Retrieved January 30, 2023 from www.sexualdiversity.org/sexuality/adolescent/1131.php
• Permalink: <a href="https://www.sexualdiversity.org/sexuality/adolescent/1131.php">10% of Minors Seeking Abortion Must Pursue Court Approval, Many Are Denied</a>