Summary: More adolescents with no history of gender dysphoria are presenting at gender clinics, especially in the US.
Gender dysphoria (GD) is the distress a person experiences due to a mismatch between their gender identity - their sense of gender - and their sex assigned at birth. The diagnostic label gender identity disorder (GID) was used until 2013 with the release of the diagnostic manual DSM-5. The condition was renamed to remove the stigma associated with the term disorder. People with gender dysphoria commonly identify as transgender. Gender nonconformity is not the same as gender dysphoria and does not always lead to dysphoria or distress.
More children and adolescents are identifying as transgender and offered medical treatment, especially in the US. But some providers and European authorities are urging caution because of a lack of strong evidence.
In a new report from The BMJ Investigations Unit, Jennifer Block, investigations reporter, looks into the evidence base behind this surge in treatment.
More adolescents with no history of gender dysphoria are presenting at gender clinics. For example, a recent analysis of insurance claims found that nearly 18,000 US minors began taking puberty blockers or hormones from 2017 to 2021, the number rising each year.
Meanwhile, the number of US private clinics focused on providing hormones and surgeries have grown from just a few a decade ago to more than 100 today.
American medical professional groups are aligned in support of "gender affirming care" for gender dysphoria, which may include hormone treatment to suppress puberty and promote secondary sex characteristics, and surgical removal or augmentation of breasts, genitals, and other physical features.
Three organisations in particular have had a major role in shaping the US approach to gender dysphoria care: The World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH), the American Academy of Pediatrics, and the Endocrine Society, all of which have guidelines or policies that support early medical treatment for gender dysphoria in young people.
These endorsements are often cited to suggest that medical treatment is both uncontroversial and backed by rigorous science, but governing bodies around the world have come to different conclusions regarding the safety and efficacy of certain treatments, notes Block.
For example, Sweden's National Board of Health and Welfare, which sets guidelines for care, determined earlier this year that the risks of puberty blockers and treatment with hormones "currently outweigh the possible benefits" for minors.
And NHS England, which is in the midst of an independent review of gender identity services, recently stated that there is "scarce and inconclusive evidence to support clinical decision-making" for minors with gender dysphoria, and that for most who present before puberty it will be a "transient phase," requiring clinicians to focus on psychological support and to be "mindful" of the risks of even social transition
Professor Mark Helfand at Oregon Health and Science University identified several deficiencies in WPATH's recommendations, such as lack of a grading system to indicate the quality of the evidence, while Professor Gordon Guyatt at McMaster University found "serious problems" with the Endocrine Society guidelines, including pairing strong recommendations with weak evidence.
Helfand explains that calling a recommendation 'evidence-based' should mean a treatment has not just been systematically studied, but that there was also a finding of high quality evidence supporting its use.
Despite these concerns, WPATH recommends that youth have access to treatments following comprehensive assessment, stating "the emerging evidence base indicates a general improvement in the lives of transgender adolescents."
Eli Coleman, lead author of WPATH's Standards of Care and former director of the Institute for Sexual and Gender Health at the University of Minnesota, told The BMJ that WPATH's new guidelines emphasise "careful assessment prior to any of these interventions" by clinicians who have appropriate training and competency to assure that minors have "the emotional and cognitive maturity to understand the risks and benefits."
But without an objective diagnostic test, others remain concerned, pointing to examples of teenagers being "fast-tracked to medical intervention" with little or no mental health involvement.
And in her interim report of a national review into services for young people with gender identity issues, Hilary Cass noted that some NHS staff reported feeling "under pressure to adopt an unquestioning affirmative approach and that this is at odds with the standard process of clinical assessment and diagnosis that they have been trained to undertake in all other clinical encounters."
For Guyatt, claims of certainty represent both the success and failure of the evidence-based medicine movement. "When there's been a rigorous systematic review of the evidence and the bottom line is 'we don't know,'" he says, then "anybody who then claims they do know is not being evidence based."
Gender Dysphoria Rising in Youth - So is Professional Disagreement | BMJ (bmj.com). SexualDiversity.org makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith. Content may have been edited for style, clarity or length.
|Latest LGBT Adolescents Publications|
The above information is from our reference library of resources relating to LGBT Adolescents that includes:
|For LGBTQ Youth Parental Support is Important|
A new study looks at parental social support and psychological control of depressive symptoms for LGBTQ youth in the United States.
Publish Date: 6th Mar 2023
|Gender Dysphoria Rising in Youth - So is Professional Disagreement|
More adolescents with no history of gender dysphoria are presenting at gender clinics, especially in the US.
Publish Date: 24th Feb 2023
|10% of Minors Seeking Abortion Must Pursue Court Approval, Many Are Denied|
U.S. states, including Colorado that have not banned abortion still do require those under age 18 to involve their parents before terminating a pregnancy.
Publish Date: 21st Jan 2023
|LGBTQ Youth in Juvenile Correctional Facilities at High Risk for Suicide and Self-Harm|
A new study finds that LGBTQ youth are disproportionally represented in juvenile correctional facilities.
Publish Date: 29th Nov 2022 - Updated: 30th Nov 2022
1How Many Genders Are There?
Alphabetical list of gender identities.
2Transgender Reporting Guide
How to write about transgender people.
3Glossary of Sexuality Terms
Definitions of sexual terms & acronyms.
4Glossary of Gender Terms
Definitions of gender related terms.
5Am I Gay? Questions to Ask
Think you may be gay or bisexual?
• Submissions: Send us your coming events and LGBTQ related news stories.
• Report Errors: Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.
• (APA): BMJ. (2023, February 24). Gender Dysphoria Rising in Youth - So is Professional Disagreement. SexualDiversity.org. Retrieved September 23, 2023 from www.sexualdiversity.org/sexuality/adolescent/1149.php
• Permalink: <a href="https://www.sexualdiversity.org/sexuality/adolescent/1149.php">Gender Dysphoria Rising in Youth - So is Professional Disagreement</a>