Author: University of Florida
Author Contact: ufl.edu
Published: 2nd Dec 2022
Peer-Reviewed Publication: Yes
Additional References: Workplace Discrimination Publications
Summary: Research reveals those in management positions demonstrate explicit and implicit bias toward others from marginalized groups and often express more implicit bias than those not in management.
Implicit bias is a form of bias that occurs automatically and unintentionally but affects judgments, decisions, and behaviors. Research has shown implicit bias can pose a barrier to recruiting and retaining a diverse scientific workforce. The three types of implicit bias:
In a study that examined bias in the workplace, a UF researcher found that those in management positions demonstrate explicit and implicit bias toward others from marginalized groups and often express more implicit bias than those not in management.
The study, published this month in Frontiers in Psychology, drew from 10 years of data publicly available from Harvard University's Project Implicit, a repository of information from more than 5 million people.
George Cunningham, professor and chair of the UF Department of Sport Management, and his co-author analyzed responses from people who identified themselves as managers and compared their assessments of racial, gender, disability and sexual orientation biases to those from people in 22 other occupational designations.
"Stereotypes and prejudices harm workplace experiences and advancement opportunities for people from minoritized and subjugated backgrounds," said Cunningham, who also is director of the Laboratory for Diversity in Sport. "While people undoubtedly experience mistreatment from coworkers and customers, our work shows that managers are also likely to express bias, particularly in implicit forms."
Cunningham explained that while a great deal of research exists using the Project Implicit data, he had not seen any that compared biases among the different professional categories. Because the web-based test provides occupational codes, he could compare people whose primary role is in management, like a CEO or varying types of mid-management, to people in other employment positions.
The study's authors learned that claims of racial, gender and disability discrimination were the most frequently filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission between 1997 and 2021.
Because sexual orientation hadn't been a federally protected employment characteristic, they drew data from UCLA's Williams Institute, which reports that 45% of those who identify as LGBTQ+ have experienced some form of discrimination at work.
"Once we saw that race, gender, disability and sexual orientation-based forms of mistreatment are all prevalent in the U.S. workforce, we determined this warranted examination of managers' biases in these areas," Cunningham said.
Implicit bias occurs automatically and unintentionally, but it affects judgements, decision-making and behaviors, Cunningham said. Research has shown that this unintentional discrimination has implications for many aspects of society, including in health care, policing, education and organizational practices.
With explicit bias, individuals are aware of their prejudices and attitudes toward certain groups.
In Cunningham's study, implicit biases were assessed using the Implicit Association Test, or IAT.
Explicit attitudes were assessed using the Feeling Thermometer, where participants responded to items measuring their attitudes toward different groups.
"With respect to explicit biases, the scores as we calculated them indicated that people working in management occupations had an explicit bias in favor of people without disabilities, men relative to women working outside the home, White people and heterosexual people," Cunningham said.
For implicit bias scores, the researchers used a previously established benchmark of degrees, including neutral, slight, moderate and strong and found managers held a moderate preference for the groups in the majority. The paper goes on to break down the results by explicit and implicit bias, by different occupations and in relation to each of the four targeted groups of people.
"Of the 176 comparisons, we found statistically significant differences in 58, or about a third of the time," Cunningham said.
Respondents to the Project Implicit survey who identified as managers had similar levels of bias to those in what researchers called white collar occupations, like medical doctors and those in the business and financial sector. They had less bias than those working in physical labor and blue-collar jobs, like food production, transportation and protective services. Additionally, the managers expressed more bias than people whose job code involved bettering the human condition and protecting the environment, like educators, artists and social scientists, according to the study.
"It's not that managers are more biased than everybody else or that they are less biased than everybody else, but it's clustered," Cunningham said. "Our original question was, do they have biases, do they vary from others with different occupation codes, and will that impact claims that employees make? This tells us, yes, they do, and the type of bias depends not only on the focus but whether it's implicit or explicit."
Cunningham said their study also showed there is a disconnect between managers' explicit and implicit bias ratings, especially when it came to disability. Their responses indicated they explicitly didn't believe they had biases regarding people with disabilities, while their implicit bias regarding this group was the highest of all the others.
The value in studies like this, Cunningham said, is to build awareness for our implicit biases.
"The more we're aware of it, the more likely we are to take steps to help lessen the impact," he said. "Training, equity advisors, checks and balances and other practices should be imbedded in the system - not once-a-year activities."
"The bigger issue, though, is to change the way our society operates," he said. "Managers can't do as much about how society functions, but they can do things about how their organizations function."
Managers Exhibit Bias Based on Race, Gender, Disability and Sexual Orientation | University of Florida (ufl.edu). SexualDiversity.org makes no warranties or representations in connection therewith. Content may have been edited for style, clarity or length.
Post to Twitter Add to Facebook
| Latest Workplace Discrimination Publications | |
|---|---|
The above information is from our reference library of resources relating to Workplace Discrimination that includes: | |
 | Harsh Workplace Pushing Women Out of Academia Researchers found a harsh workplace climate, which can include harassment and feelings of not belonging, was the most common reason women left academia. Publish Date: 21st Oct 2023 |
| Himpathy Towards Perpetrators of Workplace Sexual Harassment A new study suggests that some people are morally biased to have sympathy toward the accused in cases of workplace sexual harassment. Publish Date: 20th Mar 2023 - Updated: 11th Apr 2023 |
 | Creamy and Seductive: Gender Surveillance in Flight Attendant Work Despite airline industry attempts to cultivate diverse working environments, gendered practices and pressures persist with female cabin crew encountering expectations on appearance not extended to male counterparts. Publish Date: 17th Jan 2023 |
| Managers Exhibit Bias Based on Race, Gender, Disability and Sexual Orientation Research reveals those in management positions demonstrate explicit and implicit bias toward others from marginalized groups and often express more implicit bias than those not in management. Publish Date: 2nd Dec 2022 |
1How Many Genders Are There?
Alphabetical list of gender identities.
2Transgender Reporting Guide
How to write about transgender people.
3Glossary of Sexuality Terms
Definitions of sexual terms & acronyms.
4Glossary of Sexual Identities
Definitions of gender related terms.
5Am I Gay? Questions to Ask
Think you may be gay or bisexual?
• Submissions: Send us your coming events and LGBTQ related news stories.
• Report Errors: Please report outdated or inaccurate information to us.
• (APA): University of Florida. (2022, December 2). Managers Exhibit Bias Based on Race, Gender, Disability and Sexual Orientation. SexualDiversity.org. Retrieved May 18, 2024 from www.sexualdiversity.org/discrimination/work/1108.php
• Permalink: <a href="https://www.sexualdiversity.org/discrimination/work/1108.php">Managers Exhibit Bias Based on Race, Gender, Disability and Sexual Orientation</a>